
Why is my web traffic dropping?
This is the most common question I get from publishers: Why is my traffic dropping and what can I do about it?
It’s a multitude of things and reasons that are leading to drops for media companies, but there are answers and hope.
We’re seeing a variety of actions that are leading to recovery of that traffic and growth in some instances.
So, if your traffic is dropping, here are the things I’d check on and do that are mainly focused on growing your SEO organic traffic again:
Check basics on Google Search Console
There are a few things you should look at:
- Is your site map being sent to Google? If not, you should resubmit it. This is one way Google indexes and sees your content.
- Are some of your most important pages not being indexed? You can spot these under headings like “Crawled — not currently indexed” and “Blocked by Robots.” If they shouldn’t be blocked, resubmit them to Google.
- Google Search Console’s core vitals: This will flag pages that are slowing down your site. Identify those and talk to your CMS or developer on how to make improvements.
- Use Google’s Page Insights: Run a site speed report and find areas for improvement.
Identify stories that are dropping
It’s not difficult to identify stories that have lost the most traffic in a specific time period in Google Analytics 4. I find this especially useful to do after Google rolls out one of their updates.
- Find the stories with the biggest drop-off and update the text if it’s outdated.
- Optimize key areas like the headline, meta description, headers, links, and photo naming conventions.
- Check to see if keywords have lost traction using a tool like Ahrefs keyword explorer and update them accordingly.
Do you have bad links?
See if any of your links are getting penalized. Google has this thing called Manual Actions Report that you can find in your Google Search Console.
This is where they flag links that they are punishing you for.
- Look for spam-like content, often from paid content placements.
- Check for penalties and follow Google’s recommendations to correct any flagged issues.
Use SEO best practices for new content
Going backwards to make sure your content is well optimized is important, and addressing technical issues on your site is too. But most importantly, you need to ensure that every new piece of content follows SEO best practices.
That all starts with high-quality content, creating helpful information, and when possible, personalizing the content. Always remember, Google’s E-E-A-T focus.
SEO Checklist for Every Story:
- URL Optimization → Include 4-5 relevant keywords.
- Headline Optimization → Conversational & keyword-rich. (8-10 words)
- Meta Descriptions → Under 160 characters & includes keywords. Include a CTA.
- Story Format → Reader-first formats (Q&As, lists, numbers)
- Headers → Properly formatted (H3) and include keywords.
- Internal & External Links → Anchor text is SEO-friendly.
- Image Optimization → Alt text applied & keywords in file names.
There’s a lot to SEO but we can help
We perform audits for news organizations and help them implement the changes. Reach out to me today to find out how we can get started!
Email me at David@davidarkinconsulting.com.
We'd love to help your organization! Fill out the form below to get started.
Recent Posts

How to handle 5 everyday SEO decisions in your newsroom

Here’s a practical publisher guide to re-engaging newsletter readers

The old Facebook playbook isn’t working. What should you do now?

How publishers can build AI workflows their teams will use

Webinar: What publishers need to know about SEO in the AI era
Case Studies

The Reels strategy helping one TV news anchor grow her audience

How Pittsburgh Magazine created AI workflows their teams are now regularly using

How a unique training program is helping a university newspaper learn the digital skills newsrooms need

How analytics can make your content better and your sales case studies really effective

